Katie Staudt, Intern
A project to prevent teen pregnancy was recently launched by the City of
Baltimore’s Health Department called “Know What U Want.” From the campaign’s title, it appears to be an admirable undertaking.
After all, no one wants teen pregnancy nor does anyone object to empowering
teens to know what they want in life. However, on their website, teens will
only discover how to choose their method of birth control and learn how to “get
the goods” (which teens are assured can done without their parents’ knowledge).
Is this really empowering teens to know what they want? Well, not according to
social science.
Such a campaign presupposes that what teens want is sex and the only thing
left to “know” is what method of birth control is best for them. But the reality is sex is not ultimately what teens want. While it is
true that many teens engage in sex (nearly 48% of all
high schoolers), a majority realize afterward that sex and
hooking up is not all that it’s cracked up to be. In fact, research shows that 91% of girls who “hook up” have regrets
due to guilt or feeling used, and 80% wish it never happened. Even MTV reports that nearly 2/3 of teens wish they had waited to
have sex.
Of course, this same data could be used to suggest we need to help that
small percentage of teens who don’t have regrets know what birth control they
want. But, the reality is teens who begin sexual activity at a young
age are likely to deal with permanent negative physical, psychological, social
and economic consequences that they might not immediately realize. A Heritage research report shows that sexually
active teens have a higher probability of becoming infected by STDs, fall into
depression, and eventually have unstable marriages and live in poverty.
Even with all
these facts, it might seem worthwhile to give teens “what they want” to at
least prevent teen pregnancy. But, the reality is a number of studies have shown that contraceptives
do not prevent teen pregnancy. In fact, a recent study conducted by a professor from Duke and Yale found that
“programs that increase access to contraception are found to decrease teen
pregnancies in the short run but increase teen pregnancies in the long run.”
Teens, like all humans, want happiness and
fulfillment. Even though some seek happiness in sex, they haven’t found it
there. So if we really are trying to empower teens to
know what they want, perhaps we should begin by explaining how we are designed as humans as well as the negative
consequences when we go against our design and positive outcomes when we live
in line with it. It also might not be a bad idea to
promote healthy families and worship
because, in reality (see here
and here),
that’s where the most happiness
is found.
Very true. And while it might be argued that the correlation of sexually active teens with depression, divorce and poverty is not necessarily causal (i.e. perhaps the poor, broken families and the depressed find meaning in being sexually active), that argument cannot stand in face of the other facts you presented. Those facts of course are that clearly a high percentage of teens regret their decisions to be sexually active and the fact that depression seems to follow the decision to become sexually active. If they were depressed before and regret the decision after (often this psychologically holds the depressed in their state), then the theory that a certain kind of person becomes sexually active breaks down. Unless another solution is given to the data, the relationship between sexually active teens and depression, poverty and divorce must be causal.
ReplyDelete- Gabe Milano
P.S. Good job Katie!